Report on the first phase of Whānau Ora released

Tue 13 Oct 2015

Te Puni Kōkiri has released a report on the first phase of Whānau Ora (2010-2015). The report, Understanding whānau-centred approaches: Analysis ...

Te Puni Kōkiri has released a report on the first phase of Whānau Ora (2010-2015).

The report, Understanding whānau-centred approaches: Analysis of Phase One Whānau Ora research and monitoring results says that the first phase has focused on building provider capability to design and deliver whānau-centred approaches. It explains, "The terms ‘Whānau Ora approach’ and ‘whānau-centred approach’ refer to a culturally grounded, holistic approach focused on improving the wellbeing of whānau (families) and addressing individual needs within a whānau context."

An action research and monitoring programme tracked collectivesʼ development of whānau-centred approaches and subsequent impacts on whānau. The report analysed the data from those monitoring programmes to examine:

  • "which components of whānau-centred approaches were evident during implementation, and the degree to which they aligned with recommendations from the Taskforce on Whānau-centred Initiatives
  • the different ways whānau-centred approaches were implemented across Whānau Ora collectives
  • main barriers and enablers to these approaches
  • the impacts on whānau
  • the implications for both Whānau Ora as an initiative and Whānau Ora as a wider social sector approach."

The report is not an evaluation of Whānau Ora.

It found "intermediary improvements" for whānau included accessing services, happiness, relationships and leadership. "Higher-level improvements" included safety and education/training.

The report proposed a series of actions to undertake, some specific to the Whānau Ora Initiative and some to progress a wider Whānau Ora approach to other services:

  • "Strengthen iwi and Crown leadership for whānau
  • Apply a whānau-centred lens to existing programmes and services to guide the development of whānau-centred approaches
  • Shift funding, contracting and reporting of services to align with whānau realities
  • Assess 'matches' between whānau needs, local and regional services and resources
  • Develop socio-economic policies and programmes to meet whānau needs and realities
  • Develop health and social workforce capability in whānau-centred approaches
  • Generate sustainable funding for Whānau Ora navigators"

These actions are to be supported by further research to:

  • "Understand the full impacts on whānau of whānau-centred practice
  • Improved research and monitoring around whānau-centred approaches
  • Identifying system changes needed to support whānau-centred practice
  • Understanding whanaungatanga as 'social capital' for whānau"

Maori Party co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell said "This [the TPK report] provides a fairly good overview of the research was done for a fair number of families. We are talking about 60 action research reports, 200 monitoring reports, 895 whānau surveys. There is still more research to go on as we move into stage two, but as a comprehensive piece of information that allows us to say, 'we've got the platform right', I think we are in the right space."

Professor Mason Durie agreed that Whānau Ora was largely meeting its goals, yet there was still no integrated whole-of-Government approach and that inefficient funding and contracting structures made some change difficult. He said "What hasn't come through as strong is how Government can develop a framework that would facilitate integrated development. It's about 50-years-old, the urgency. We can get locked into sectors - people don't live their lives in sectors."

Other reports

The report follows the Whānau Ora: The first four years report released by Auditor-General Lyn Provost in May 2015. This report acknowledged the innovative approach to service delivery and the successes for families who had benefited from a whānau-centred approach, but also critiqued how Whānau Ora is understood in the sector, the way funding was used, and the lack of cross-government support.

Auditor General Lyn Provost said "... the providers are mainly required by their contracts with government agencies to deliver services to individuals. When we did our work, the Ministries of Health and Social Development had no plans to change to a funding model that would take advantage of the effort and $68 million paid to providers to help them shift to whānau-centred service delivery. The signals currently sent by different parts of government are, at best, mixed."

On 21 September 2015, Pasifika Futures released a progress snapshot of the first year of the Pacific Whānau Ora programme and its commissioning activities. The report provides information on the 11 organisations which received core commissioning funding, innovation programmes, grants and achievements.


Whānau Ora agency responds to misleading statements, Press release: Te Pou Matakana, Scoop, 01.07.2016

TPK struggles to measure Whānau Ora outcomes, Press release: NZ Labour Party, Scoop, 01.07.2016

Whānau Ora critics get it wrong, Press release: NZ Government, 30.06.2016

Whānau Ora Cash-Cow Rumbles On Unchecked, Press release: NZ First Party, Scoop, 30.06.2016 

Whānau Ora delivering positive outcomes, Press release: Pasifika Futures Limited, Scoop, 30.06.2016

Whānau Ora not living up to promise - Labour, Radio NZ, 30.06.2016

Whānau Ora goes international, Radio NZ, 05.10.2015

Whanau Tahi rides on back of Whanau Ora, Press Release: Te Whanau O Waipareira Trust, Scoop, 02.10.2015

Families move foward with Pasifika Futures, Manukau Courier, 28.09.2015

Power Play: The Maori Party's Whanau Ora problem, Radio NZ, 11.09.2015

Positive signs in Taranaki that Whanau Ora policy is making a real difference, Taranaki Daily News, 10.09.2015

Key: Govt's Whānau Ora funding will continue, 3 News, 08.09.2015

Govt will continue funding Whānau Ora: Key, NZ City, 08.09.2015

Whānau Ora approach not enough: Labour, Otago Daily Times, 08.09.2015

Take a look at … report on whānau ora, NZ Doctor, 08.09.2015

'100 pages of self-justification', Radio NZ, 08.09.2015

Scheme would benefit from 'whole-of-govt' approach, Radio NZ, 08.09.2015

VIEWPOINT: The State cannot understand whānau; the State cannot restore whānau, Mana Magazine, 07.09.2015

Whānau Ora report largely positive, NewsTalk ZB, 07.09.2015

Whānau Ora report: Family-centred approach working, Stuff, 07.09.2015

Whānau Ora gave welfare to nearly 50k people, 3 News, 07.09.2015

Whānau Ora evaluation too late, Labour Party, 07.09.2015

Whānau Ora: 'Still a lot to be done', Radio NZ, 07.09.2015

Benefit in family approach - Whānau Ora report, NZ Herald, 07.09.2015

Whānau Ora report due out today, Radio NZ, 07.09.2015

A much anticipated Whānau Ora report, Radio NZ, 07.09.2015

Reports shows success of Whānau Ora approach, Beehive, 04.09.2015

Image: Sunlit Flax by Brenda Anderson. Licence: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Image: Brenda Anderson